Discount Tire

Discount Tire Alternatives & Competitors

ReturnPolicy Score
/ 5
Visit Site
Home > Stores > Discount Tire > Competitors
Discount Tire

Discount Tire Alternatives & Competitors

ReturnPolicy Score

The ReturnPolicy score is calculated based on several factors including: convenience, customer service, speed of refund, flexibility and users’ ratings.

/ 5
Convenience & Flexibility
Customer Service
Speed of Refund
Users' Rating

In the world of tire retailing, stands out as a significant player. Founded in 1960 by Bruce T. Halle, the company has grown from a single store in Ann Arbor, Michigan, to a nationwide chain known for its customer service and satisfaction guarantee. With the rise of e-commerce, has effectively taken its extensive selection of tires and wheels online, offering competitive pricing and convenient features like their Tire Size Calculator and online appointment scheduling.

Discount Tire Top Deals and Special Offers See Now

The tire industry is fiercely competitive, and while has made a name for itself, it faces stiff competition from a variety of other retailers, each vying for a share of the market. These competitors range from specialized tire sellers to comprehensive automotive service providers, some with brick-and-mortar legacies and others born in the digital age.

Let's take a closer look at each of these competitors, exploring what they bring to the table and how they stack up against's offerings.

Discount Tire Competitors Breakdown

Tire Rack has carved out a niche as a go-to destination for gearheads and everyday drivers alike. Known for their extensive selection and detailed consumer reviews, they also provide a wealth of research tools and tire testing information. Their competitive edge lies in their user-friendly website and their 'Test Track' feature, which gives insight into tire performance under various conditions.

While Tire Rack might not have the physical presence that does through its Discount Tire stores, it compensates with a network of recommended installers and a reputation for excellent customer support.

Goodyear Tires

Goodyear is not just a tire manufacturer but also a retailer. Their direct-to-consumer approach on allows customers to purchase tires and schedule installations at Goodyear service centers. Unlike, Goodyear focuses on its own brand of tires, which could be a draw for brand loyalists but might limit choices for those seeking a broader selection.

  • Strong brand recognition
  • Manufacturer-direct purchases
  • Limited selection compared to multi-brand retailers
  • Might be pricier than discount-focused sellers

Firestone Complete Auto Care

Firestone Complete Auto Care, much like Goodyear, offers a combination of tire sales and automotive services. Their advantage lies in their comprehensive care approach, providing a one-stop-shop for consumers. While their tire selection includes various brands, they also promote their own Firestone and Bridgestone tires.

The brand's emphasis on full auto care services sets them apart from, which specializes more narrowly in tires and wheels.

Big O Tires

Big O Tires operates both online and through a franchised retail network, offering a mix of tire brands, including their exclusive Big O brand. Their service portfolio extends beyond tires, positioning them as a competitor that overlaps with both's tire focus and the broader service scope of Firestone and Goodyear.

The added value of Big O Tires lies in their service warranties and the convenience of their many locations, potentially giving them an edge in customer service.

America's Tire

America's Tire is actually the online presence of the retail chain owned by the same parent company as Discount Tire. While they are essentially the same entity, they operate under different names in different regions. This branding strategy allows them to cater to regional preferences and maintain a local feel.

Les Schwab is a regional powerhouse with a loyal customer base, known for their exceptional service and community involvement. They offer a range of tires and automotive services, similar to Firestone and Big O Tires. Les Schwab prides itself on its customer-oriented service and hassle-free warranty, which could sway some customers who are on the fence.

Their regional focus and the legacy of their brand's customer service philosophy make them a notable competitor in the areas they serve.

Tires Plus

Tires Plus offers a balance between tire retail and car maintenance services. They have a strong online presence where customers can purchase tires and schedule services, much like The chain is backed by Bridgestone, which can lend credibility to their offerings but might also narrow the selection for customers seeking non-Bridgestone brands.

Pep Boys

Pep Boys has a long history in the automotive industry, providing both parts and services. Their wide array of offerings, from tires to car accessories, poses competition to, especially for customers looking for a comprehensive shopping experience.

Their nationwide presence and recognized brand give them a competitive edge, but their broader focus might dilute their appeal to those looking for a tire specialist.

Discount Tire

Discount Tire Direct is the mail-order arm of Discount Tire and essentially serves the same customer base as, just through a different distribution channel. They offer free shipping to customers, which could be a deciding factor for online shoppers.


NTB (National Tire and Battery) is another competitor that brings a combination of tire sales and car maintenance services. Their aggressive pricing and frequent promotions make them a direct competitor to's discount pricing strategy.

Their nationwide network of stores ensures that they are a convenient option for many customers, but their service quality can vary from store to store.

While Edmunds is primarily known for its automotive reviews and buying advice, it also provides a platform for tire purchasing through partnerships. This informational edge and their trusted advice could sway consumers who start their tire buying process with research on


CarGurus, much like Edmunds, is best known for its role in the car buying and selling process. However, their extensive user base and automotive knowledge make them a potential funnel for tire sales through affiliate partnerships or direct sales initiatives.


AutoZone is a well-known name in the auto parts industry. Although they are more focused on car parts than tires, they do offer tire-related products and could decide to expand into the tire sales space, leveraging their extensive store network and brand recognition.


JustAnswer is a bit of an outlier as it is a platform for expert advice rather than a product retailer. However, as they provide automotive expertise, there is potential for them to influence tire purchases through recommendations and troubleshooting.

Advance Auto Parts

Advance Auto Parts is another major player in the auto parts industry, with a vast network of stores. They could become a more direct competitor to if they chose to expand their tire offerings, leveraging their existing customer base and distribution channels.

SimpleTire operates solely online, offering a large selection of tires with a focus on easy shopping and competitive prices. Their business model is similar to's approach to online sales, and they compete on convenience, pricing, and selection.

  • Free shipping on all orders
  • User-friendly interface
  • Competitive pricing
  • Lacks physical stores for in-person service
  • May not have the same level of brand recognition as older, established companies
Discount Tire Top Deals and Special Offers See Now