Progressive

Progressive Alternatives & Competitors

ReturnPolicy Score
3.3
star-rating
3.3
/ 5
Visit Site
Home > Finance & Insurance > Progressive > Competitors
Progressive

Progressive Alternatives & Competitors

ReturnPolicy Score

The ReturnPolicy score is calculated based on several factors including: convenience, customer service, speed of refund, flexibility and users’ ratings.

3.3
/ 5
3.0
Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
3.0
Speed of Refund
0
Users' Rating
Progressive.com's Top 5 Competitors

Progressive has been a heavyweight in the insurance industry since it was founded in 1937. With their iconic 'Flo' character and their innovative 'Name Your Price' tool, they've made a name for themselves as a company that's both customer-focused and tech-savvy. They were also one of the first to offer auto insurance quotes online, making them a pioneer in the digital insurance space.

But as with any successful business, Progressive.com has its fair share of competition. From industry giants to tech-forward startups, the car insurance marketplace is crowded with contenders vying for consumers' attention. So, let's take a cruise through the competition and see how they stack up against Progressive's offerings.

Keep in mind, while we're comparing these companies, each one brings its own unique perks and policies to the table. It's not just about price—customer service, coverage options, and user experience all play crucial roles in choosing the right insurer.

Progressive Competitors Breakdown

Geico

Geico is often recognized for their cheeky gecko mascot and memorable catchphrase. But beyond their marketing, they're a force to be reckoned with in the insurance world. As one of Progressive's biggest competitors, Geico prides itself on offering low rates and a user-friendly online experience for customers seeking auto insurance.

Their online tools and mobile app make managing policies and filing claims pretty straightforward, which is a big plus for the digitally inclined. Their competitive pricing often positions them at the top of the list for cost-conscious drivers.

Pros
  • User-friendly online platform
  • Competitive pricing
Cons
  • Might lack personalized service of smaller agencies

State Farm

ReturnPolicy Score

5.0 / 5

State Farm

5.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
5.0
Customer Service
5.0
Speed of Refund
5.0
Users' Rating
0
Read State Farm’s return policy

State Farm is another insurance titan, and they've built their brand on a foundation of personal relationships through a vast network of local agents. While Progressive focuses on their online presence, State Farm emphasizes the value of having a personal agent to guide customers through the insurance process.

They offer a wide range of insurance products, and their prices are generally competitive, though perhaps not always the lowest. Their customer service is often highlighted as a strong point, which can be a big draw for those who value face-to-face interaction.

Allstate Insurance Company

Allstate stands out with their 'Safe Driving Bonus Check' and 'Drivewise' program, which reward customers for safe driving habits. They match Progressive's tech-forward approach with their own set of online tools and resources for policy management and claims filing.

Allstate's rates can be on the higher side, but their focus on rewards and discounts for safe drivers can offset those costs for some customers. Their local agent network also adds a personal touch to their customer service.

Usaa.com

USAA is a bit different from the rest because they cater exclusively to military members, veterans, and their families. This focus allows them to offer some of the best rates and customer service in the industry, which is a major reason why they're a strong competitor to Progressive.

Their eligibility requirements mean that not everyone can take advantage of USAA's offerings, but for those who do qualify, the company is known for its integrity and commitment to its members.

Liberty Mutual

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Liberty Mutual

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Liberty Mutual’s return policy

Liberty Mutual's 'Liberty Stands With You' slogan is backed by their diverse range of coverage options and their unique benefits, like accident forgiveness and new car replacement. They're a competitor because they offer a mix of traditional insurance with innovative features that appeal to a broad audience.

Their rates can be competitive, and they also offer a variety of discounts, but some customers might find their pricing higher than some of the other industry leaders.

Nationwide Insurance

Nationwide boasts a 'On Your Side' review to help customers understand and optimize their insurance coverage. They're in the race with Progressive because of their comprehensive coverage options and solid reputation for customer service.

While they may not always have the lowest prices, their focus on customer education and resources can be a valuable asset to those looking to understand their insurance policies better.

Farmers Insurance

Farmers has a history of stability and has built a reputation for personalized service through their agent network. They bring a human touch to the insurance process, which can be a contrast to Progressive's digital-first approach.

Their coverage options are robust, and while their rates may not be the lowest, the level of personal service can make Farmers an attractive option for those who prefer dealing with an agent directly.

Travelers

Travelers is known for their extensive insurance offerings and their commitment to innovation in the industry. They've been around for a long time, and their experience shows in their comprehensive coverage options and resources for policyholders.

Their prices can be competitive, and they often offer discounts that can make their policies more attractive to savvy customers looking for a deal on their insurance.

AAA | American Automobile Association

AAA is synonymous with roadside assistance, but they also offer competitive insurance products. They're a contender in the insurance space because of their strong brand recognition and the added value of their membership benefits.

Their insurance rates can be competitive, especially for members, and their customer service is generally well-regarded, making them a solid choice for those who appreciate the added perks of AAA membership.

American Family Insurance

American Family Insurance, or AmFam, puts a strong emphasis on community and family. They offer a personalized approach to insurance, with a focus on building long-term relationships with their customers.

Their rates are generally competitive, and they provide a range of insurance products that can be tailored to individual needs, making them a strong competitor to Progressive for those seeking a more personal touch.

NerdWallet

NerdWallet isn't an insurance provider but a financial comparison website. They've become a competitor to insurers like Progressive by providing comprehensive reviews and comparisons of insurance rates and coverage options, helping consumers make more informed decisions.

Their tools and resources allow customers to compare prices and coverage across multiple insurers, including Progressive, which adds a layer of transparency to the insurance shopping process.

Bankrate

Similar to NerdWallet, Bankrate is a financial comparison site that offers consumers information on various financial products, including insurance. Their competitive edge comes from their detailed analysis and the ability to compare insurance quotes from different providers.

They help customers find the best rates and coverage, providing a channel through which Progressive must compete to attract and retain customers.

The Zebra

The Zebra is another comparison site but is specifically focused on insurance. They've become a significant player in the industry by offering a platform for easy comparison of insurance policies from many providers, including Progressive.

Their real-time quote comparison tool gives consumers the power to shop around for the best policy, making them a valuable resource for anyone looking to potentially save money on their car insurance.

Sign Up for the ReturnPolicy.com Newsletter

Thanks for Joining!