Shoe Carnival

Shoe Carnival Alternatives & Competitors

ReturnPolicy Score
4.0
star-rating
4.0
/ 5
Visit Site
Home > Stores > Shoe Carnival > Competitors
Shoe Carnival

Shoe Carnival Alternatives & Competitors

ReturnPolicy Score

The ReturnPolicy score is calculated based on several factors including: convenience, customer service, speed of refund, flexibility and users’ ratings.

4.0
/ 5
4.0
Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
0
Users' Rating
Shoecarnival.com's Top 5 Competitors

Shoe Carnival, a leading retailer in the footwear and accessories space, has built a name for itself since its inception in 1978. With a unique open-floor plan and an emphasis on creating an engaging shopping experience, Shoe Carnival has worked hard to carve out a niche in a competitive market. Known for their vast selection of brand-name and private-label merchandise, the company has grown from a single store in Evansville, Indiana, to a successful chain with hundreds of locations across the United States.

Shoe Carnival and the Competitive Landscape of Footwear Retail

Top Pick
Zappos
ReturnPolicy Score

5.0 / 5

Zappos

5.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
5.0
Customer Service
5.0
Speed of Refund
5.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Zappos’s return policy
Visite Site
2
DSW
ReturnPolicy Score

2.9 / 5

DSW

2.9 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
3.5
Customer Service
3.5
Speed of Refund
3.5
Users' Rating
1.0
Read DSW’s return policy
Visite Site
3
Finish Line
ReturnPolicy Score

2.5 / 5

Finish Line

2.5 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
3.0
Customer Service
3.0
Speed of Refund
3.0
Users' Rating
1.0
Read Finish Line’s return policy
Visite Site
4
Foot Locker
ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Foot Locker

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Foot Locker’s return policy
Visite Site
7
Famous Footwear
ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Famous Footwear

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Famous Footwear’s return policy
Visite Site
8
Nike
ReturnPolicy Score

3.8 / 5

Nike

3.8 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.5
Customer Service
4.5
Speed of Refund
4.5
Users' Rating
1.8
Read Nike’s return policy
Visite Site
9
Adidas
ReturnPolicy Score

2.5 / 5

Adidas

2.5 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
2.5
Customer Service
2.5
Speed of Refund
2.5
Users' Rating
0
Read Adidas’s return policy
Visite Site
10
Skechers
ReturnPolicy Score

3.8 / 5

Skechers

3.8 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
3.0
Read Skechers’s return policy
Visite Site
Shoe Carnival Top Deals and Special Offers See Now

The brand's focus on value, variety, and a fun shopping environment has attracted a loyal customer base. However, as the retail landscape evolves, Shoe Carnival faces stiff competition from a variety of players in the field, ranging from specialized sports and designer footwear outlets to general department stores and online marketplaces.

Let's take a look at how Shoe Carnival stacks up against 20 of its competitors, each bringing their unique strengths to the table in the battle for consumers' feet and wallets.

Shoe Carnival Competitors Breakdown

Zappos

1 Zappos
ReturnPolicy Score

5.0 / 5

Zappos

5.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
5.0
Customer Service
5.0
Speed of Refund
5.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Zappos’s return policy

Zappos is known for its exceptional customer service, free shipping, and a 365-day return policy, making it a formidable competitor. Their wide range of shoes and accessories, coupled with a user-friendly website, positions them as a direct rival to Shoe Carnival's customer-centric approach.

While Shoe Carnival prides itself on its in-store experience, Zappos has mastered the online shopping experience, offering customers a hassle-free way to shop for shoes.

DSW

2 DSW
ReturnPolicy Score

2.9 / 5

DSW

2.9 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
3.5
Customer Service
3.5
Speed of Refund
3.5
Users' Rating
1.0
Read DSW’s return policy

DSW, or Designer Shoe Warehouse, offers a broad selection of shoes at value prices, much like Shoe Carnival. DSW's expansive inventory and focus on designer brands at discounted rates attract a similar customer base looking for deals on high-quality footwear.

DSW's rewards program and exclusive discounts provide incentives for customer loyalty, challenging Shoe Carnival's own value proposition.

Finish Line

ReturnPolicy Score

2.5 / 5

Finish Line

2.5 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
3.0
Customer Service
3.0
Speed of Refund
3.0
Users' Rating
1.0
Read Finish Line’s return policy

Finish Line is a leader in athletic footwear, catering to the needs of fitness enthusiasts and sneakerheads. With a strong presence both online and in major department stores, Finish Line offers a curated selection of the latest performance and sport-style footwear which competes with Shoe Carnival's athletic shoe segment.

Their partnerships with top brands and exclusive releases are significant draws for customers, making them a competitive player in the athletic shoe market.

Foot Locker

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Foot Locker

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Foot Locker’s return policy

Foot Locker's focus on youth culture and its reputation as a go-to destination for sneaker enthusiasts places it in direct competition with Shoe Carnival's athletic and casual sneaker offerings. With a global footprint and strong brand recognition, Foot Locker appeals to a similar demographic but with a more concentrated focus on sports and lifestyle sneakers.

Their exclusive releases and collaborations with high-profile athletes and celebrities create a buzz that attracts a dedicated following.

Shoes.com

shoes.com

Shoes.com, an online retailer, offers a vast array of footwear for the whole family. With competitive pricing and a wide selection, they challenge Shoe Carnival's market share by leveraging the convenience of online shopping and frequent promotions.

Their user-friendly interface and seamless shopping experience cater to consumers who prefer to shop from the comfort of their homes.

Journeys

Journeys targets the trendy teen and young adult markets with a focus on skateboard and street style footwear. Their cool and edgy brand image appeals to a younger audience, which overlaps with a segment of Shoe Carnival's customer base.

Journeys' emphasis on fashion-forward styles and unique brand offerings make it a strong competitor, particularly in the youth market.

Famous Footwear

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Famous Footwear

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Famous Footwear’s return policy

Famous Footwear competes with Shoe Carnival by offering a selection of brand-name shoes at discounted prices. With a mix of online and brick-and-mortar presence, Famous Footwear's strategy of convenience and value aligns closely with Shoe Carnival's.

Their frequent sales and family-friendly approach make them a direct competitor, especially in suburban markets.

Nike

8 Nike
ReturnPolicy Score

3.8 / 5

Nike

3.8 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.5
Customer Service
4.5
Speed of Refund
4.5
Users' Rating
1.8
Read Nike’s return policy

Nike's direct-to-consumer platform offers the latest in athletic and lifestyle footwear, often setting trends in the industry. As a manufacturer and retailer, Nike competes with Shoe Carnival by providing exclusive products that are not available through other channels.

Nike's strong brand loyalty and innovative technology in footwear can draw customers away from multi-brand retailers like Shoe Carnival.

Adidas

9 Adidas
ReturnPolicy Score

2.5 / 5

Adidas

2.5 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
2.5
Customer Service
2.5
Speed of Refund
2.5
Users' Rating
0
Read Adidas’s return policy

Adidas, much like Nike, has a compelling brand presence and attracts consumers with its own direct-to-consumer sales. Their offerings in sports performance and lifestyle categories present a challenge to Shoe Carnival's array of athletic footwear.

Adidas' focus on sustainability and design innovation also appeals to consumers who are looking for brands with a strong identity and ethos.

Skechers

ReturnPolicy Score

3.8 / 5

Skechers

3.8 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
3.0
Read Skechers’s return policy

Skechers caters to a wide demographic with their diverse range of comfortable and casual shoes. Known for their memory foam insoles and lifestyle-driven designs, Skechers competes with Shoe Carnival in areas of comfort and affordability.

Their direct-to-consumer and wholesale strategies enable them to reach a broad audience, similar to Shoe Carnival's approach.

Nordstrom

ReturnPolicy Score

5.0 / 5

Nordstrom

5.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
5.0
Customer Service
5.0
Speed of Refund
5.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Nordstrom’s return policy

Nordstrom's reputation for high-quality products and excellent customer service places it at the higher end of the retail spectrum. While Shoe Carnival focuses on value and variety, Nordstrom attracts a more upscale market with its selection of designer brands and luxury services.

However, their expansive shoe department and online presence do make them a competitor for customers seeking quality and a premium shopping experience.

Macy's

12 Macy's
ReturnPolicy Score

3.8 / 5

Macy's

3.8 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.5
Customer Service
4.5
Speed of Refund
4.5
Users' Rating
1.5
Read Macy's’s return policy

Macy's, as a department store, offers a wide range of footwear within its larger portfolio of products. With frequent sales and a strong brand, Macy's competes with Shoe Carnival in the family footwear space, offering options for every occasion.

Macy's loyalty programs and seasonal promotions present a challenge to Shoe Carnival's customer retention efforts.

Kohl's

13 Kohl's
ReturnPolicy Score

4.6 / 5

Kohl's

4.6 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
5.0
Customer Service
5.0
Speed of Refund
5.0
Users' Rating
3.4
Read Kohl's’s return policy

Kohl's is another department store competitor that offers an extensive selection of shoes for the whole family. Known for its competitive pricing and Kohl's Cash rewards, Kohl's competes on value, much like Shoe Carnival.

Their nationwide presence and focus on value-driven shopping experiences make them a notable competitor in the family footwear market.

Poshmark

ReturnPolicy Score

3.0 / 5

Poshmark

3.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
3.0
Customer Service
3.0
Speed of Refund
3.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Poshmark’s return policy

Poshmark's unique model as a social commerce marketplace allows individuals to buy and sell new or used shoes, among other fashion items. This peer-to-peer platform competes with Shoe Carnival by offering discounted prices on a vast array of shoe brands.

The opportunity for consumers to find rare or discontinued items makes Poshmark an attractive alternative for savvy shoppers.

Dick's Sporting Goods

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Dick's Sporting Goods

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Dick's Sporting Goods’s return policy

Dick's Sporting Goods is a leading retailer in the sports and fitness realm, providing a comprehensive selection of athletic footwear. The overlap with Shoe Carnival's sports shoe offerings makes Dick's a direct competitor, especially with their focus on sports-specific performance footwear.

Their expertise in sports gear and strong community involvement through sponsorships and events give them an edge in the athletic footwear market.

Rack Room Shoes

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Rack Room Shoes

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Rack Room Shoes’s return policy

Rack Room Shoes operates on a similar model to Shoe Carnival, with a focus on family footwear and value pricing. Their 'Buy One Get One' promotions and rewards program directly compete with Shoe Carnival's discount strategies.

With a significant brick-and-mortar presence and a growing online store, Rack Room Shoes is a noteworthy competitor in the budget-friendly shoe market.

Nordstrom Rack

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Nordstrom Rack

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Nordstrom Rack’s return policy

Nordstrom Rack provides customers with discounted designer footwear, serving as the off-price retail division of Nordstrom. Their ability to offer high-end brands at reduced prices competes with Shoe Carnival's value-centric business model.

The Rack's appeal to bargain-hunting consumers looking for luxury brands at lower prices presents a challenge to Shoe Carnival's market share.

Lyst

18 Lyst
ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Lyst

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Lyst’s return policy

Lyst is a fashion aggregator that allows customers to shop from multiple retailers in one place. Their wide range of footwear options from various brands and stores competes with Shoe Carnival by offering convenience and comparison shopping.

The platform's ability to cater to fashion-conscious consumers who are looking for the best deals across the web makes it a formidable competitor in the online shoe retail space.

JCPenney

ReturnPolicy Score

3.1 / 5

JCPenney

3.1 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
3.5
Customer Service
3.5
Speed of Refund
3.5
Users' Rating
1.9
Read JCPenney’s return policy

JCPenney, another department store with a strong footwear section, offers competitive pricing and a variety of brands. Their frequent promotions and private-label offerings compete with Shoe Carnival's strategy of providing value to families and individuals alike.

JCPenney's nationwide presence and customer loyalty initiatives make them a competitor in the budget-conscious retail market.

Dillard's

ReturnPolicy Score

4.0 / 5

Dillard's

4.0 / 5

Convenience & Flexibility
4.0
Customer Service
4.0
Speed of Refund
4.0
Users' Rating
0
Read Dillard's’s return policy

Dillard's provides a mix of mid-range and designer footwear, aiming for a more upscale customer than Shoe Carnival. Their quality merchandise and seasonal sales events attract customers who are willing to spend more for premium brands and styles.

While they cater to a different market segment, they still compete with Shoe Carnival on the broader spectrum of family footwear retail.

Shoe Carnival Top Deals and Special Offers See Now